Michael Carrick’s first 5 matches at MU: An early nightmare?

Manchester United have officially named Michael Carrick as the caretaker manager. Having formerly managed Boro, he is anticipated to inject new life into this faltering team. The main issue is that “stormy times” are imminent for Carrick given the tough upcoming fixtures against the Red Devils.

Currently, MU sits 7th in the Premier League standings. What’s notable is the gap between them and the Top 4 (which qualifies for the Champions League) is not very large. The Red Devils are only 3 points behind the 4th spot. If successful, Carrick will surely be rewarded, possibly with a long-term contract and significant funding for MU.

This means, theoretically, Carrick still has plenty to strive for. A series of positive results could push MU straight into the top 4. However, looking at the opponents, MU will definitely have to give more than 100% effort.

Man City (home, 17/1)

The Manchester derby in Carrick’s first match is a brutally tough challenge. Man City are title contenders with stable gameplay, a superior squad, and the incredibly fast integration of Semenyo. With MU still settling under new leadership, this is a comprehensive but extremely demanding test. A loss wouldn’t be catastrophic, but a heavy defeat would put Carrick in a very difficult position moving forward.

Arsenal (away, 25/1)

After giving their all against Man City, MU will need to quickly regain form, confidence, and determination whether they win or lose, as the next match is against Arsenal. According to the schedule, MU must travel to Emirates to face the league leaders Arsenal.

The Gunners are well-organized, press intensely, and are very dangerous at home. Coach Mikel Arteta’s squad is highly motivated to win a trophy this season and won’t hesitate to crush the Red Devils to solidify their top position and “threaten” any rivals aiming to disrupt them in the remainder of the 2025/26 season.

Fulham (home, 1/2)

After two tough battles against strong clubs, MU will face Fulham. Compared to Man City and Arsenal, Fulham seems more manageable but is not necessarily easy to beat. Fulham often proves difficult, especially when considered the underdog. For Carrick, this is almost a must-win game. Simply put, losing here would put him in serious trouble.

Tottenham (home, 7/2)

Tottenham defeated MU in the Europa League final, directly causing Manchester United to miss out on European competition this season. Facing Tottenham again while the opponent is still struggling could be an opportunity for the Red Devils to “avenge,” but success is uncertain. This is not just about points but also a psychological battle where Carrick must prove MU is no longer like it was under Ruben Amorim. Moreover, Thomas Frank is desperate to beat MU because a loss could cost him his job immediately.

West Ham (away, 10/2)

Traveling to West Ham’s stadium holds many “traps.” The London club is fighting relegation and performing poorly. The question is whether MU can show anything against such an opponent? Can they win? This season, MU has often “rescued” teams fighting for points, including Wolves.

It’s going to be tough... Carrick

Carrick’s first 5 matches at MU might be among the toughest schedules any new manager has faced. Previously, the team played poorly, failing to improve their position, got knocked out of the FA Cup, and saw their coach leave. Now, the upcoming 5 matches promise even more challenges. Three of the five opponents are top Premier League teams, though their current form varies: Man City, Arsenal, and Tottenham. The other two, Fulham and West Ham, also have the potential to cause surprises. In the Premier League, don’t assume a lower-ranked opponent means an easy win; sometimes the opposite happens.

Given MU’s instability and inconsistent personnel, the management will need to give Carrick time, and the former Boro coach hopes for the same. It’s unrealistic to expect Carrick to quickly establish a clear identity, restore fighting spirit, and rebuild player confidence. These things require gradual steps.

If MU fails to perform well, they will fall further behind in the Top 4 race. That’s something MU wants to avoid but if it happens, they must accept it positively. Conversely, if Carrick can help the team get through this turbulent period with acceptable results, it will be a huge morale boost for the rest of the season. Without new signings and having to rely on what Amorim left behind, it’s tough for Carrick right from the start. But that’s MU. Even Van Gaal, Mourinho, and Rangnick had to leave. Managing MU is a difficult puzzle but enough to challenge any coach.